Fediverse Moderation

From XPUB & Lens-Based wiki

Here comes Moderation.

Examples

Manetta's suggestion :

https://github.com/f0x52/glitch-soc/blob/main/CODE_OF_CONDUCT.md

constantz :

https://pad.constantvzw.org/p/guidelines.questions

https://constantvzw.org/wefts/orientationspourcollaboration.en.html

Research

Table 1: The prevalence of Rules in Mastodon and Reddit sub-communities. Rules can be both prescriptive and restrictive and can cover multiple content categories. For example, "Treat others with respect" is a prescriptive personality rule, "Don't be a jerk" is restrictive personality rule and "Be civil and be kind. If you need to criticise, punch up, never down. Hate speech, intended to incite or offend, is not acceptable" is a both prescriptive and restrictive rule that covers multiple categories, including personality, hate speech, and harassment. "Mastodon Instances" refers to those in the sample dataset (100 instances, 690 rules), and "Subreddits" refers to those in Fiesler and colleagues large-scale dataset [18].

from https://dl.acm.org/doi/fullHtml/10.1145/3584931.3606970

Rule Type Mastodon Instances Subreddits
Restrictive 93% 99.4%
Prescriptive 83% 99.8%
Hate Speech 71% 1.6%
Reddiquette/Mastodon Covenant 67% 5.9%
Harassment 64% 2.7%
NSFW 60% 4.1%
Personality 53% 30.4%
Content Warnings 50% N/A
Illegal Content 48% N/A
Consequences/Moderation 43% 90.5%
Spam 42% 1.7%
Incitement of Violence 34% N/A
Mis/Disinformation/Conspiracy 32% N/A
Doxxing/ Personal Info 31% 0.5%
Advertising & Commercialization 30% 7.6%
Images 28% 0.8%
Brigading/Dogpiling 27% 0.2%
Behavior/Content/Format Allowed 21% 99.9%
Impersonation 20% N/A
Codes of Conduct 17% N/A
Copyright/ Piracy 16% 1.0%
Server Interference 14% N/A
Automated Tools 14% N/A
Off-topic/topic Specific 12% 15.6%
Politics 9% 0.1%
Low-Quality Content 8% 0.8%
Reposting/Crossposting 8% 1.6%
Trolling 7% 0.3%
Links & Outside Content 7% 24.2%
Spoilers 4% 0.7%

Drafts

https://pad.xpub.nl/p/Fediverse_Moderation